Â
| Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | |
| Byrd | Samuel | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Amoros | Sandy | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Chapman | Ben | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Campanella | Roy | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Combs | Earle | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Furillo | Carl | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Crosetti | Frankie | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Gilliam | Jim | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Dickey | Bill | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Hoak | Don | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Farrell | Doc | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Hodges | Gil | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Gehrig | Lou | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Kellert | Frank | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Hoag | Myril | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Reese | Pee Wee | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Jorgens | Arndt | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Robinson | Jackie | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Lary | Lyn | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Shuba | George | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Lazzeri | Tony | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Snider | Duke | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Ruth | Babe | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Walker | Rube | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Sewell | Joe | Hitter | 1932 | Yankees | Zimmer | Don | Hitter | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Allen | Johnny | Pitcher | 1932 | Yankees | Erskine | Carl | Pitcher | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Gomez | Lefty | Pitcher | 1932 | Yankees | Labine | Clem | Pitcher | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| MacFayden | Danny | Pitcher | 1932 | Yankees | Loes | Billy | Pitcher | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Pennock | Herb | Pitcher | 1932 | Yankees | Newcombe | Don | Pitcher | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Pipgras | George | Pitcher | 1932 | Yankees | Podres | Johnny | Pitcher | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Ruffing | Red | Pitcher | 1932 | Yankees | Spooner | Karl | Pitcher | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| McCarthy | Joe | Manager | 1932 | Yankees | Alston | Walter | Manager | 1955 | Dodgers | |
| Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | |
| Bartell | Dick | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Agee | Tommie | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Berger | Wally | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Boswell | Ken | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Chiozza | Lou | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Clendenon | Donn | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Danning | Harry | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Garrett | Wayne | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Davis | Kiddo | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Gaspar | Rod | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Leiber | Hank | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Grote | Jerry | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Leslie | Sam | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Harrelson | Bud | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Mancuso | Gus | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Jones | Cleon | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| McCarthy | Johnny | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Kranepool | Ed | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Moore | Jo-Jo | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Pfeil | Bobby | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Ott | Mel | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Shamsky | Art | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Ripple | Jimmy | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Swoboda | Ron | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Whitehead | Burgess | Hitter | 1937 | Giants | Weis | Al | Hitter | 1969 | Mets | |
| Castleman | Slick | Pitcher | 1937 | Giants | Cardwell | Don | Pitcher | 1969 | Mets | |
| Gumbert | Harry | Pitcher | 1937 | Giants | Gentry | Gary | Pitcher | 1969 | Mets | |
| Hubbell | Carl | Pitcher | 1937 | Giants | Koosman | Jerry | Pitcher | 1969 | Mets | |
| Melton | Cliff | Pitcher | 1937 | Giants | McAndrew | Jim | Pitcher | 1969 | Mets | |
| Schumacher | Hal | Pitcher | 1937 | Giants | McGraw | Tug | Pitcher | 1969 | Mets | |
| Smith | Al | Pitcher | 1937 | Giants | Seaver | Tom | Pitcher | 1969 | Mets | |
| Terry | Bill | Manager | 1937 | Giants | Hodges | Gil | Manager | 1969 | Mets | |
| Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | |
| Bauer | Hank | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Blair | Paul | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Berra | Yogi | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Chambliss | Chris | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Brown | Bobby | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Dent | Bucky | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Coleman | Jerry | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Jackson | Reggie | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Collins | Joe | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Johnson | Cliff | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| DiMaggio | Joe | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Munson | Thurman | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Hopp | Johnny | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Nettles | Graig | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Jensen | Jackie | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Pinella | Lou | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Mantle | Mickey | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Randolph | Willie | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| McDougald | Gil | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Rivers | Mickey | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Mize | Johnny | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Spencer | Jim | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Rizzuto | Phil | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | Stanley | Fred | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Woodling | Gene | Hitter | 1951 | Yankees | White | Roy | Hitter | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Lopat | Eddie | Pitcher | 1951 | Yankees | Beattie | Jim | Pitcher | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Morgan | Tom | Pitcher | 1951 | Yankees | Figueroa | Ed | Pitcher | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Ostrowski | Joe | Pitcher | 1951 | Yankees | Gossage | Goose | Pitcher | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Raschi | Vic | Pitcher | 1951 | Yankees | Guidrey | Ron | Pitcher | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Reynolds | Allie | Pitcher | 1951 | Yankees | Hunter | Catfish | Pitcher | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Shea | Spec | Pitcher | 1951 | Yankees | Tidrow | Dick | Pitcher | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Stengel | Casey | Manager | 1951 | Yankees | Lemon | Bob | Manager | 1978 | Yankees | |
| Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | |
| Berra | Yogi | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Backman | Wally | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Blanchard | Johnny | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Carter | Gary | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Boyer | Clete | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Dykstra | Lenny | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Cerv | Bob | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Foster | George | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| DeMaestri | Joe | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Heep | Danny | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Gardner | Billy | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Hernandez | Keith | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Howard | Elston | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Johnson | Howard | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Kubek | Tony | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Knight | Ray | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Lopez | Hector | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Mitchell | Kevin | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Mantle | Mickey | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Santana | Rafael | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Maris | Roger | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Strawberry | Darryl | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Richardson | Bobby | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Teufel | Tim | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Skowron | Moose | Hitter | 1961 | Yankees | Wilson | Mookie | Hitter | 1986 | Mets | |
| Coates | Jim | Pitcher | 1961 | Yankees | Aguilera | Rick | Pitcher | 1986 | Mets | |
| Daley | Bud | Pitcher | 1961 | Yankees | Darling | Ron | Pitcher | 1986 | Mets | |
| Ford | Whitey | Pitcher | 1961 | Yankees | Fernandez | Sid | Pitcher | 1986 | Mets | |
| Sheldon | Rollie | Pitcher | 1961 | Yankees | Gooden | Dwight | Pitcher | 1986 | Mets | |
| Stafford | Bill | Pitcher | 1961 | Yankees | McDowell | Roger | Pitcher | 1986 | Mets | |
| Terry | Ralph | Pitcher | 1961 | Yankees | Ojeda | Bob | Pitcher | 1986 | Mets | |
| Houk | Ralph | Manager | 1961 | Yankees | Johnson | Davey | Manager | 1986 | Mets | |
| Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | Last Name | First Name | Position | Year | Team | |
| Dark | Al | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Boggs | Wade | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Gardner | Billy | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Duncan | Mariano | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Hofman | Bobby | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Fielder | Cecil | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Irvin | Monte | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Girardi | Joe | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Katt | Ray | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Jeter | Derek | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Lockman | Whitey | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Leyritz | Jimmy | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Mays | Willie | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Martinez | Tino | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Mueller | Don | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | O'Neill | Paul | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Rhodes | Dusty | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Raines | Tim | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Taylor | Bill | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Sierra | Ruben | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Thompson | Hank | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Strawberry | Darryl | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Westrum | Wes | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Williams | Gerald | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Williams | Davey | Hitter | 1954 | Giants | Williams | Bernie | Hitter | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Antonelli | Johnny | Pitcher | 1954 | Giants | Gooden | Dwight | Pitcher | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Gomez | Ruben | Pitcher | 1954 | Giants | Key | Jimmy | Pitcher | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Grissom | Marv | Pitcher | 1954 | Giants | Pettitte | Andy | Pitcher | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Hearn | Jim | Pitcher | 1954 | Giants | Rivera | Mariano | Pitcher | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Liddle | Don | Pitcher | 1954 | Giants | Rogers | Kenny | Pitcher | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Maglie | Sal | Pitcher | 1954 | Giants | Wickman | Bob | Pitcher | 1996 | Yankees | |
| Durocher | Leo | Manager | 1954 | Giants | Torre | Joe | Manager | 1996 | Yankees |